PrlUnicorn wrote:G wrote:PrlUni corn wrote:
Current Standings:
Keepers of the Isle
Celestial Keeper / ArchMage Claire Farron Gained: 2013-10-18
Keeper of Air Vacant
Keeper of Earth Colleen MacLeod-Fenner Gained: 2013-09-28
Keeper of Fire Kheldar Drasinia Gained: 2013-07-22 Defended: 2013-08-27 # Defenses: 1
Keeper of Water XanthVanBokkelen Gained: 2013-10-18
Which was pretty much what Lem already posted.
The discussion now should be if that should be included as part of the Achievement. Because if so, then Diamonds and Overlords should be able to give that achievement, yet Overlords can't have Squires.
My argument is that Archmage Neophytes should not be eligible for the achievement, despite the fact that they're also a "Keeper."
Frankly, I'm leaning to Archmage Keeper's Neophytes are not eligible and the wording will need to change on the achievement page.
If you want to continue to argue for an Archmage keeper counting, feel free, it won't convince me because Overlords and Diamond's underlings aren't eligible for their respective achievements.
I understand that it was pretty much what Lem had already posted, the point being that a look at the standings page shows the information right out in the store window. The AM has also been listed as a Keeper since the first standings were published on this site
http://www.ringsofhonor.org/dom/DoMstan ... e=20050104 It's not right to arbitrarily change that after at least 8 years of a standing precedent.
How many years has the debate of Sword =/= Fists =/= Magic gone on? This is one of those situations where Magic's rules, rank and title system totally differ from DoS and DoF. As Jake pointed out, there are differences between sports.
G, you previously verified the Archmage as valid as a Keeper for the achievement.
http://www.ringsofhonor.org/forums/view ... 945#153945
I also said
In other words, anyone who has requested that achievement and it was to just to Emeralds and Mages were incorrectly awarded.
Now the question is, do I go through all those requests and revoke, or just let it sit as is and be more vigilant in the future.
I think, honestly, that I'm going to keep it as is, and be more careful on checking the verification.
If you want me to revoke the improperly awarded achievement, I will. Otherwise acknowledge that in the future, I'm going to be more vigilant at verification to ensure that only the elemental keepers neophytes are awarded the achievement
as it was intended.
Point is, the wording was incorrect. The achievement was incorrectly awarded.
The wording is now in line with how the achievement was intended and in the future, I'm going to award it to the correct requesters. I am also not going to revoke it from those who have previously been rewarded as it was MY error in doing so.
That said, just because I awarded it in the past does NOT mean it's going to be done in the future. The issue is corrected and Going Forth, only CORRECT requests will be honored.
G'nort Dragoon-Talanador
Duel of Swords Legend. Best In The World™.
First All Time DoS Title Holder.
Listed as "Daddy" in your daughters contacts list.